The manual way comes first, in Google Ads itself. Then the same problem as Goldbeater finds it, every day, without anyone asking.
What ad strength rates, and what it doesn't
Ad strength is Google’s rating of a responsive search ad: Incomplete, Poor, Average, Good or Excellent, with action items saying what would raise it. Google calls it a feedback tool for the variety of an ad’s assets: it’s worked out from how well the ad’s headlines and descriptions match the ad group’s keywords, how many there are, and how many sitelinks the ad can show, and it changes whenever the keywords, the assets or the account’s structure do.
Google says it isn’t used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score or who wins the auction, and doesn’t decide whether an ad can serve. It doesn’t read your landing page either. Google reports that advertisers who raised their responsive search ads and sitelinks from Poor to Excellent saw 15% more conversions on average, and recommends at least two responsive search ads rated Good or Excellent in every ad group. An ad group can run three, and the keywords per ad group guide covers how many ads one needs. The experiments guide shows how to compare two ads in one ad group.
A responsive search ad takes up to 15 headlines of up to 30 characters and up to 4 descriptions of up to 90, and Google assembles them into combinations for each search. Ad strength asks whether it has enough of them, saying different things and holding your keywords, for those combinations to fit the searches your keywords match. Performance Max asset groups have a rating of their own, read differently. The character limits guide has each line’s limit, and how Google counts it.
| What it reads | What Google asks for |
|---|---|
| Keywords | Your ad group's most relevant keywords in the headlines, each held whole in one headline; one over 30 characters goes in a description |
| How many | Up to 15 headlines and 4 descriptions; the ad needs at least 3 and 2 |
| Variety | Each headline and description saying something different: a selling point, a benefit, a call to action |
| Sitelinks | At least 6, across the account, the campaign and the ad group, and dynamic sitelinks turned on |
| Pins | As few as you can; where a position must be pinned, 2 or 3 different lines pinned to it |
How to find the ads rated Poor or Average
- Go to Campaigns › Ads.
- If there’s no Ad strength column, select the columns icon, open Attributes, check Ad strength and select Apply.
- Add a filter for Ad type, under Attributes, and check Responsive search ad.
- Read the ratings an ad group at a time. Where no ad in an ad group reads Good or Excellent, select the best one’s rating to read Google’s suggestions for it.
A suggestion to include more keywords asks for the ad group’s keywords whole: Google counts a keyword only where one headline holds all of it, never split across two. So read the ad’s headlines beside its keywords.
| Headline | Pinned | Keyword it holds |
|---|---|---|
| Cedar & Pine Interiors | Position 1 | None |
| Corner Sofas | No | corner sofa |
| Shop Corner Sofa Beds | No | corner sofa bed |
| Free Delivery | No | None |
| Sofas Made to Last | No | None |
| Order Online Today | No | None |
| Visit Our Showroom | No | None |
| Free Delivery on Sofas | No | None |
| Shop Sofas Today | No | None |
What raises it on a responsive search ad
- Put your keywords in the headlines, whole. Use the ad group’s most relevant keywords; one too long for a 30-character headline goes in a description. Keyword insertion can add them too.
- Give it as many headlines and descriptions as you can, up to 15 and 4, each saying something the others don’t: what you sell, a selling point, a problem you solve, a call to action. Rewordings of one line add combinations without adding anything to choose between.
- Give it at least 6 sitelinks across the account, the campaign and the ad group, and turn on dynamic sitelinks. Google counts every sitelink in the ad’s branch of the account. The sitelinks guide covers adding them.
- Pin as little as you can. More on that below.
| Instead of | Write | What it adds |
|---|---|---|
| Free Delivery on Sofas | Sectional Sofas | A keyword, held whole |
| Shop Sofas Today | L Shaped Sofas in 40 Fabrics | A keyword and a selling point |
| Order Online Today | Modular Corner Sofas | A keyword, held whole |
| Sofas Made to Last | Solid Oak Frames | Proof, not a promise |
The rating recalculates each time you change an asset, so the editor shows straight away whether a change helped. Once it reads Good or better, Google says to keep watching it, since a change to the keywords can move it again.
Pin as little as you can
Pinning a headline or description to a position makes it show only there, and stops any other line showing in its place. Because that leaves fewer lines to match a search, Google says pinning isn’t recommended for most advertisers and can lower ad strength. If every position is pinned, the unpinned lines don’t show at all.
- Where a line must show in every ad, such as a disclaimer, pin it to Headline position 1, Headline position 2 or Description position 1, which always show. A line pinned to Headline position 3 or Description position 2 isn’t guaranteed to.
- Where you pin, pin 2 or 3 different lines to the position, so Google can test them. Near-identical lines pinned together restrict it and can lower the rating.
- Final URL expansion overrides pins: where it’s on and Google sends a click to a more relevant page, it doesn’t use the pinned lines. The Dynamic Search Ads guide covers what that setting does.
In Corner sofas, pinning a second version of the name, such as Cedar & Pine Sofas, to position 1 beside Cedar & Pine Interiors keeps the name first and gives Google two to test.
Ad strength on a Performance Max asset group
An asset group’s rating reads its breadth, whether it has every type of asset it needs to serve on every kind of inventory, and its depth, how much variety it has within each. The Performance Max guide covers what an asset group is, and the rest of the campaign.
| Rating | What Google says it means |
|---|---|
| Poor | Only the minimum assets to launch, so it serves on some of the inventory available |
| Average | Every asset type, so it can serve everywhere, but too little variety |
| Good | Every asset type, with good variety and varied text |
| Excellent | Every type, the optional ones too: at least 6 sitelinks, your own videos in horizontal, square and vertical rather than generated ones, and all 15 headlines and 5 descriptions |
Google’s recommended assets for an asset group:
| Asset | Recommended | Most | Required |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headlines | 11 or more | 15 | Yes, 3 |
| Long headlines | 2 or more | 5 | Yes, 1 |
| Descriptions | 4 or more | 5 | Yes, 2 |
| Landscape images (1.91:1) | 4 or more | 20 | Yes |
| Square images (1:1) | 4 or more | 20 | Yes |
| Portrait images (4:5) | 2 or more | 20 | No |
| Square logo | 1 | 5 | Yes |
| Videos | 1 each: horizontal, vertical, square | 15 | No |
| Sitelinks | 6 or more | 20 | No |
Google can make videos from the assets you give it when you have none of your own, but recommends uploading at least one, and Excellent needs yours. Where text customization is on, the text Google writes counts toward the rating as yours does. Google also says it may lower ratings as it finds new ways to guide your mix of assets, and that those updates don’t change your results.
- Go to Campaigns › Assets › Assets and open the Asset coverage tab.
- Read each asset group’s Ad Strength beside its counts of headlines, descriptions, images, videos, sitelinks and logos.
- Select View recommendations under a rating to see what Google would add to reach Excellent. Where the list and the group disagree, Google says the ad editor view has the most up-to-date rating.
Ad strength on a Demand Gen ad
A Demand Gen ad has a rating too, from Incomplete to Excellent, shown in the ad editor and in the asset report. Beside the rating Google gives a next step and a progress indicator for each type of asset. Incomplete means the ad lacks the minimum an ad needs. What the rating reads is coverage: whether the ad holds an image or a video in every shape Google can show it in. Good takes all three shapes, horizontal, square and vertical, and Excellent takes three of each.
Google’s guidelines for an image ad:
| Rating | Images | Text and the rest |
|---|---|---|
| Average | One horizontal or one square (1:1), and one vertical (4:5 or 9:16) | One headline of 30 characters or fewer, one description, a logo, a landing page URL and a business name |
| Good | One horizontal, one vertical (4:5 or 9:16) and one square (1:1) | The same as Average |
| Excellent | Three horizontal, three vertical and three square | Three distinct headlines of 30 characters or more, three distinct descriptions of 60 or more, a logo, a landing page URL and a business name |
That table calls a horizontal image 16:9. Google’s asset specifications for Demand Gen give a horizontal image as 1.91:1, 1200 by 628 pixels recommended, and keep 16:9 for a horizontal video, so make the image at 1.91:1.
A video ad reaches Good with a video in each of the three shapes, or with one horizontal video and video enhancements turned on, which lets Google make the square and the vertical one from it. The Demand Gen guide covers the rest of the campaign.
Goldbeater raises a Demand Gen ad group where Google rates the best of its ads Poor or Average. Where Google hasn’t rated its ads yet, it raises the ad group if none of its image ads holds what the table asks of Good: an image in each shape, a headline, a description and a logo. A video or carousel ad is judged by Google’s rating alone.
What it looks like when Goldbeater finds it
Every day Goldbeater reads every enabled ad’s and asset group’s rating, with Google’s own suggestions, and the assets behind it:
- Responsive ads Google rates Poor or Average: an ad group whose best ad Google rates Poor or Average, judged by its best ad, since a weaker ad beside a Good one is a test. Only ad groups one of whose ads was seen in the last 8 weeks, in a campaign that can serve. Medium where the best is Poor and the ad group spent a thousandth of the account’s 30 days, else low. The advice is Google’s suggestions for the best ad, word for word, and where Google asks for keywords, the finding lists the ad group’s keywords and whether a headline holds each. An ad group for competitors’ names is never told to put them in its headlines. The trademarks guide covers a competitor’s name in a keyword and in an ad. Goldbeater reads a Demand Gen ad group’s ads too, and the Demand Gen guide covers their formats and specs.
- Asset groups too thin to serve everywhere: an asset group rated Poor (medium) or Average (low), with what Google’s ad strength asks it to add, and what Performance Max takes from the campaign, such as sitelinks, sent to the campaign. And an asset group with no video or no portrait image of its own, whatever its rating: the videos Google makes, paused assets and videos that no longer play don’t count.
- A headline pinned alone to one position: a position of a responsive search ad that one headline or description is pinned to alone, in an ad seen in the last 8 weeks. Low. It offers to unpin it without recommending it, since a line that has to show there, your name or wording you’re required to use, wants one or two others pinned beside it instead, which you choose in Google Ads.
None of them puts a dollar figure on a rating, since Google doesn’t use it in the auction, and none writes headlines or images for you: those are yours.
No ad in Corner sofas rates better than Average for ad strength
Sofas — Phrase › Corner sofas
The best of its 2 ads rates Average for ad strength, with 9 of 15 headlines and 3 of 4 descriptions, 2 of them pinned.
- Impr., 8 weeks
- 6,780
- Clicks, 8 weeks
- 276
- Cost, 8 weeks
- $638
- Conv., 8 weeks
- 7
| Corner Sofas | Average | 9 | 3 | 2 | 4,820 | 212 | 6 |
| Sofas on Sale | Poor | 6 | 2 | 1 | 1,960 | 64 | 1 |
| "l shaped sofa" | No |
| "modular corner sofa" | No |
| "sectional sofa" | No |
| "corner sofa bed" | Yes |
| "corner sofa" | Yes |
Ad groups where Google rates no ad better than Poor or Average for ad strength: headlines that say the same thing, too few of the ad group's keywords in them, or too many pinned, so Google has fewer good combinations to try. A Demand Gen ad is judged by the pictures in each shape, the headlines and the description Google's own table asks of a Good one. It reads ads before they launch too, when a rewrite costs the least. Google doesn't use the rating in the auction; it's feedback on the ad's variety.
Edit the ad in Corner sofas that Google rates highest. Google's suggestions for it: Try including more keywords in your headlines. Try adding a few more unique headlines or unpinning some assets. A keyword counts only where one headline holds all of it.
The steps under What to do are the fix. Goldbeater drafts no change for this one.
This is “Responsive ads Google rates Poor or Average” on a sample account. See what it finds in your own account and what the fix is worth, and ask your AI analyst about any finding.
Get a free first lookThe ads in the table are the sample’s two, and the keywords below them are the ones no headline of the better ad holds whole, first. The same for a Performance Max asset group:
Rugs in Performance Max — All products has average ad strength
Performance Max — All products › Rugs
Google rates its ad strength average, and it has no video of its own, so Google makes one from its images (it has made 3), and no portrait image, the format several feeds use.
- Headlines
- 11
- Descriptions
- 3
- Images
- 11
- Videos of its own that play
- 0
- Videos Google made
- 3
- Cost, 30 days
- $1,180
- Conv., 30 days
- 3.4
- ROAS
- 4.00
Groups Google rates Poor or Average for ad strength: too few, or too similar, assets to assemble a good ad for every placement. And groups with no video or portrait image of their own, where Google shows a video it made from your images, or has no image of yours for the placements that take a portrait one.
Add 4 headlines, 2 descriptions and a vertical video to Rugs in Google Ads, as Google's ad strength asks, with different angles rather than rewordings, and 2 sitelinks to its campaign, Performance Max — All products, where Performance Max takes them from.
The steps under What to do are the fix. Goldbeater drafts no change for this one.
This is “Asset groups too thin to serve everywhere” on a sample account. See what it finds in your own account and what the fix is worth, and ask your AI analyst about any finding.
Get a free first lookRepeated lines across an ad group’s ads have a guide of their own, and the audit checklist has every ad and asset line with where to find it in Google Ads.
Questions
- Does ad strength affect Ad Rank or Quality Score?
- No. Google says ad strength isn’t used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score or auction wins, and doesn’t decide whether an ad can serve. It’s feedback on the variety of the ad’s headlines and descriptions and how well they match your keywords.
- What is a good ad strength in Google Ads?
- Good or Excellent. Google recommends at least two responsive search ads rated Good or Excellent in each ad group.
- Why is my ad strength Poor when the ad has 15 headlines?
- Ad strength reads more than the count: whether your keywords are held whole in the headlines, whether the lines say different things, how many sitelinks the ad can show, and how much is pinned. Select the rating in the Ads table to read Google’s suggestions.
- Does pinning headlines lower ad strength?
- It can. Google says pinning leaves fewer lines to match each search and isn’t recommended for most advertisers. Where a line must show, pin 2 or 3 different lines to its position rather than one.
- How many sitelinks does ad strength need?
- At least 6, across the account, the campaign and the ad group, for a responsive search ad to reach Good or better, and dynamic sitelinks turned on. A Performance Max asset group needs 6 to reach Excellent.